Skip to main content

Law 9 of 21

Foul Play in Rugby: Law 9

Prohibits obstruction, unfair play, dangerous play, and misconduct. Sanctions include penalties, yellow cards (10-minute suspension), and red cards (permanent dismissal).

Foul PlayUpdated

Common foul play types: obstruction, dangerous play, and misconduct
Common foul play types: obstruction, dangerous play, and misconduct

Law 9 in plain English

Foul play is anything a player does inside the playing enclosure that breaks Law 9. The law sorts it into five groups:

Obstruction: Getting in an opponent's way unfairly. An offside player must not deliberately block opponents or get involved in play. Nobody may deliberately stop an opponent from tackling the ball carrier or from getting a chance at the ball, and a ball carrier must not run into an offside team-mate to shield themselves. Two players racing for the ball may only bump shoulder to shoulder.

Unfair play: Deliberately breaking any law, deliberately knocking or throwing the ball out of the playing area, trying to fool the match officials into penalising an opponent, and wasting time.

Repeated infringements: A player who keeps breaking the laws, or a team that keeps committing the same offence. When several players in one team keep making the same offence, the referee warns the whole team, and the next player to do it gets a yellow card.

Dangerous play: Anything reckless or dangerous to others, such as leading with the elbow or forearm, jumping into or over a tackler, physical or verbal abuse (biting, punching, contact with the eyes, striking, stamping, tripping, kicking), early, late or dangerous tackles, tackles that lead to head contact or go above the sanction line, tackling a player without the ball or in the air, lifting a player and dropping them on their head or upper body, dangerous play in scrums, rucks and mauls, retaliation, and the flying wedge.

Misconduct: Anything against the spirit of good sportsmanship, and not respecting the referee, for example by arguing with decisions or playing on after the whistle.

Sanctions:

  • Penalty: the sanction for almost every Law 9 offence. Wasting time and not lowering a lifted team-mate safely give a free-kick instead.
  • Caution or card: on top of the penalty, a player who commits foul play must be cautioned (warned), shown a yellow card or sent off. Law 9 does not say which act gets which, apart from the yellow card after a team warning (above) and the red card for a second yellow (below).
  • Yellow card: the player is suspended for 10 minutes of playing time and waits in the sin-bin (two minutes in sevens and tens). A second yellow-card offence by the same player means they are sent off.
  • Red card: the player is sent off and takes no further part in the match. Normally the team cannot replace them. In elite rugby, a replacement may come on after 20 minutes, unless the red card was for an intentional and highly dangerous act.

Foul play that stops a probable try also leads to a penalty try (Law 8.3).

Real-World Examples

Scenario

A defending winger runs across the field without the ball to block the path of an attacker who is chasing a kick.

Outcome

Obstruction. The winger is deliberately stopping the attacker from getting a chance to play the ball without competing for it (Law 9.4). The attacking team gets a penalty where it happened, and as with any foul play the winger must also be cautioned, shown a yellow card or sent off.

Scenario

A flanker makes multiple infringements at the breakdown, coming in from the side, not releasing the ball, and offside, over the course of several minutes despite the referee's warnings.

Outcome

Each offence is a penalty, and a player who keeps breaking the laws commits foul play (Law 9.9). Having already been warned, the flanker can be shown a yellow card and suspended for 10 minutes of playing time (Law 9.29).

Scenario

A prop attempts to tackle the opposing fly-half and makes contact above the shoulder line, hitting the fly-half in the head area.

Outcome

Dangerous tackle. A tackle that leads to head contact, or goes above the sanction line in open play, breaks Law 9.13. The fly-half's team gets a penalty, and the prop must also be cautioned, shown a yellow card or sent off. Law 9 does not say which of these a given tackle gets; the referee decides.

Scenario

A defensive player picks up a ball carrier, lifts them to beyond horizontal, and drives them into the ground head-first.

Outcome

This breaks Law 9.18, which bans lifting a player and then dropping or driving them so their head or upper body hits the ground. The ball carrier's team gets a penalty, and the tackler must be cautioned, shown a yellow card or sent off. A player who is sent off takes no further part and cannot be replaced, except in elite rugby, where a replacement may come on after 20 minutes unless the act was intentional and highly dangerous (Law 9.30).

Scenario

A scrum-half whose team leads with 30 seconds left picks the ball up at a ruck and deliberately throws it into touch.

Outcome

Unfair play: deliberately throwing the ball out of the playing area breaks Law 9.7(b). The opposing team gets a penalty where she threw it, but no closer than 15 metres to the touchline (Law 20.1). She must also be cautioned, shown a yellow card or sent off. Doing it again would also be a repeated infringement (Law 9.8, 9.9).

Common questions

What is the difference between a yellow card and a red card in rugby?

A yellow card means the player has been cautioned and suspended, usually for 10 minutes of playing time (two minutes in sevens and tens), and must wait in the sin-bin before returning. A red card means the player is sent off and takes no further part in the match, and normally the team cannot replace them. In elite rugby, the team may bring on a replacement after 20 minutes, unless the red card was for an intentional and highly dangerous act.

What is a high tackle in rugby?

A high tackle is a tackle above the sanction line in Law 14.1: the shoulders in elite rugby, and the waist or base of the sternum in community rugby. Law 9.13 also treats any tackle that leads to head contact as dangerous. The sanction is a penalty, and the tackler must also be cautioned, shown a yellow card or sent off.

What is a tip tackle in rugby?

Tip tackle is the common name for what Law 9.18 bans: lifting an opponent off the ground and then dropping or driving them so that their head or upper body hits the ground. The laws do not use the term itself. The sanction is a penalty, and the tackler must also be cautioned, shown a yellow card or sent off.

What is obstruction in rugby?

Obstruction is unfairly getting in an opponent's way. Law 9 bans an offside player deliberately blocking an opponent or joining in play, deliberately stopping an opponent from tackling the ball carrier or getting a chance at the ball, a ball carrier running into an offside team-mate to shield themselves, and obstructing anyone while the ball is dead. Charging or obstructing a player who has just kicked is also banned (Law 9.25). The sanction is a penalty.

Can you shoulder charge in rugby?

Not on a ball carrier. Law 9.16 bans charging into or knocking down a ball carrier without trying to grasp them. The only charge allowed is shoulder to shoulder between two players running for the ball (Law 9.1). The sanction is a penalty, and the player must also be cautioned, shown a yellow card or sent off.